Jibber Jabber About Bach's Goldberg Variations Aria
Variation 25
Goldberg Variations, BWV 988

I'm Johann Sebastian Bach, and I'm happy to walk you through Variation 25 of my Goldberg Variations. You'll hear a slow adagio in G minor, the longest piece in the set, with a winding, chromatic melody that Wanda Landowska called "the black pearl". On this site my fellow composers and I also teach you to recognize our pieces when you hear them, so I invite you to put yourself to the test .
---
Two Keyboards and One Patient Listener
Think of this variation as a slow walk at dusk rather than a race, and settle in before you press play. I wrote it for a harpsichord with two keyboards, which lets the player give the melody and the bass line different colors. Follow the top line first, because it moves in very quick little notes, many of them sliding by half steps, and that gives it a sighing, searching sound. Underneath, the bass line from the aria is still there, so whenever you feel lost in the melody, drop down and follow it like a handrail on a staircase.A Title I Never Wrote
Here's a confession: I never gave Variation 25 a nickname. The nickname came much later, when Wanda Landowska called it "the black pearl". I think she heard what I hoped any listener would hear: something dark, rare and carefully made, with a glow that comes out of the shadows. A pearl also takes its time to form, and this variation is in no hurry either.What Kind of Piece Is This?
People sometimes ask what grand form this is, and the honest answer is that it's a variation. That means it follows the bass line and chord progression of the aria and leaves the aria's melody behind, so I was free to write an entirely new tune on the same foundation. For our listening I'll divide it into three stretches, the opening, the long middle and the way home, and that's my guide for you rather than a map I drew in advance. Let's take them one at a time, and I think you'll find each has its own mood.Section 1: The Lamp Gets Turned Down
The piece begins in G minor at an adagio pace, which is slow enough that every note has time to be noticed. After the bright G major of the aria, the change of color is the first thing you'll feel, as if someone had lowered the lamp in the room. The melody enters quietly and already leans on those half-step slides, so it sounds like someone thinking out loud. The pulse is a gentle three beats to a bar, and you can sway to it if you do so very slowly.Section 2: The Scenic Route
The middle is where the piece earns its reputation as generally the longest in the set. The melody winds through its chromatic turns, and the fast little notes keep spilling out in long phrases that seem reluctant to end. Listen for the moments when the mood brightens a little and then clouds over again, like a memory that comes and goes. Don't try to guess where it's heading, because the pleasure here is in being a little lost while the bass line keeps the road steady underneath you.Section 3: The Long Way Home
In the last stretch the restless melody gradually loses its urgency, and the music grows calmer. The sighing half steps are still there, but now they sound more like acceptance than questions. When it ends you'll be sitting in a quiet that feels different from the quiet you started in. That quiet is worth a moment of your time before you move on to whatever comes next.Your Turn to Press Play
Now it's your turn: press play and let the music fill the room. As you listen, keep in mind the sighing top line, the steady bass underneath and the three stretches we just walked through. If your attention wanders, that's perfectly fine, since this piece is patient and will wait for you. I hope you enjoy hearing it as much as I enjoyed writing it.---
I hope you enjoyed learning about the listen guide for Variation 25 of the Goldberg Variations. Did it make you want to sit down with that slow, searching G minor music and hear it again? I'd like you to leave with the sense that the black pearl is only one small part of a much larger journey. After its long, quiet walk, the music still has the rest of the work ahead of it, and each variation shows the same bass line in a new light. There are more aspects of the Goldberg Variations to explore, from the canons that appear at every third step to the cheerful medley of Variation 30. The aria even returns at the very end, and by then it sounds like an old friend you now know much better. If you're curious, I invite you to click on the links provided and keep exploring the Goldberg Variations. Take your time with them, the way I asked you to take your time with this variation. I think you'll find that the music has more to tell you each time you come back.
