Beefy Tones with at Beethoven's Symphony No 9
II. Scherzo Molto Vivace
Symphony No. 9 in D minor, Op. 125 ("Choral")

I'm Ludwig van Beethoven, and I'm about to explain the II. Scherzo Molto Vivace movement of my Symphony No 9. You'll hear a fugue open this dark, driving movement in D minor, then a bright hymn-like trio in D major breaks through, and that sudden change of mood is worth your time. Recognizing our pieces by sound is something my fellow composers and I teach you here on this site, so why not put yourself to the test right after the music stops?
---
Put Your Ears on a Treasure Hunt
Before you press play, I'd ask you to listen for a tune that keeps getting passed around, because that is the whole game in this movement. I open with a fugue, which just means one instrument states a theme and the others take it up one after another. Try to catch each new entrance as it arrives, and notice how dark and tightly packed the music feels, with hardly a moment to catch your breath. Later a calmer, hymn-like tune steps in as a contrast, and that is your cue to let your shoulders drop for a little while.Why I Called It a Scherzo
I gave this movement the title Scherzo because that is the kind of piece I wanted in the second spot, with the Adagio coming third. A scherzo is traditionally a quick, driving movement in three beats to the bar, and I marked mine Molto vivace. I also enjoy letting a title promise one thing while the music, dark and concentrated, delivers something a bit different. So think of the name as the label on a tin, and don't be surprised if the contents are stranger than the picture on the front.Choosing the Shape
For this movement I settled on a scherzo and trio. That means a main section comes first, then a contrasting trio, and then the main section returns. The main part lives in D minor and the trio moves to D major, with three beats to the bar in the main part. I'm only touching on the sections here, because next I'll walk you through them one by one, and I think you'll enjoy the trip.Section 1: The Fugue Takes the Floor
The scherzo proper begins in D minor, marked Molto vivace, and it starts with that fugue rather than with a tune everyone can hum straight away. The mood is dark and urgent, and the entrances stack up so the texture gets denser with each new voice. I wanted a feeling of energy that never relaxes, so the pulse of three beats to the bar keeps pushing forward. Hold on to this sound, because it is the home base of the movement, and everything that follows is measured against it.Section 2: A Hymn Opens the Window
Then the trio arrives, and the key moves from D minor to D major, which is like opening a window in a dark room. The mood changes from restless to warm, and the hymn-like melody sounds almost like a song of thanks after all that tension. The marking for the movement runs from Molto vivace to Presto, so even here the music is never far from motion. Notice how the contrast works, because the brightness only feels so bright after the fugue has made you wait for it.Section 3: The Dark Mood Comes Home
After the trio, the main section returns, and we are back in D minor with the fugue and its restless energy. You'll recognize the opening this time, and I hope that gives you the pleasure of hearing something familiar come back changed by what happened in between. The mood has gone full circle, from tension to a brief moment of light and back to tension again. That return is what gives the whole movement its shape, like a story that ends where it began but with you knowing more.Over to You
Now it's your turn to hear this movement for yourself. Press play, settle in, and let the music carry you along without trying to catch everything on the first go. As you listen, you might keep in mind the fugue, the hymn-like trio in D major, and the way the main section returns. I hope the journey through this movement thrills you as much as it thrilled me when I wrote it.---
That's the end of our walk through the second movement, the Scherzo, Molto vivace, of my Symphony No 9. Did you enjoy this listen guide? I hope it gave you a few things to listen for the next time the fugue begins and the theme starts traveling from one instrument to the next. It's a movement that sounds a little different each time you return to it, because once you know where the entrances are, you start to hear how the whole thing fits together. There's still a lot more of this symphony to explore. After the Scherzo comes the slow third movement, a peaceful and yearning set of variations on two themes. After that comes the finale, where the Joy theme grows through one variation after another, and human voices join the orchestra. Voices in a symphony were unusual in my day, so that moment still feels like a door opening into a new room. If you'd like to go further, please click on the links below to continue exploring Symphony No 9. I'd be glad to have you along for the rest of the journey.
