Uncorking the Goodness of Brahms's Symphony No 1
IV. Adagio - Più andante - Allegro non troppo, ma con brio
Symphony No. 1 in C minor, Op. 68

I'm Brahms, and I'm about to explain the IV. Adagio - Più andante - Allegro non troppo, ma con brio, the finale of my Symphony No 1. You'll hear the trombones enter for the first time in the whole symphony, with a solemn chorale that follows the alphorn tune, before the music breaks through into a C major triumph. Since my fellow composers and I also teach you on this site to recognize our pieces when you hear them, come and try the Trainer once the final chords have faded.
---
Who Does What in the Finale
Think of this finale as a story told by the whole orchestra, and let the strings be your main guide, because they carry the long, singing lines that hold everything together. The timpani give the music its pulse, and the woodwinds and horns add color along the way, so keep your ear open for them as the mood changes. The big surprise is the trombones, which play in this movement and nowhere else in the symphony, so when they finally arrive it feels like a door opening. If you only remember one thing, listen for the moment the music stops being tense and starts sounding like a hymn.A Title That Reads Like a Recipe
The title is a list of Italian instructions, because I wanted the players to know exactly how the movement changes speed as it goes. Adagio means slow and unhurried, and Più andante means a little more flowing, so the music starts to walk instead of crawl. Allegro non troppo, ma con brio means fast but not too fast, and with spirit, which was my way of asking for energy without a stampede. The Più allegro near the end simply asks for even more speed, and it is the last push before the finish.The Shape of the Thing
Choosing the form for this finale was an adventure in itself, and I'll tell you the shape rather than hand you a textbook label. It begins with a slow introduction in C minor, and then the music speeds up into a long, confident main part that ends in C major. I'll only sketch the sections here, because I want to walk through each of them one at a time in the paragraphs that follow. Think of it as a journey from a dark, uncertain start to a bright and open ending.Section 1: Adagio, or Clearing My Throat in the Dark
The movement opens in C minor and at a slow pace, and the mood is tense, as if the music hasn't yet decided what it wants to say. This slow introduction brings in a new melody, which is a sign that I had something fresh to say after three movements already behind us. Don't wait for a tune to grab onto yet, because here you are mostly feeling the atmosphere. That uneasy mood is the starting point of the whole story, so it's worth sitting with it for a while.Section 2: Più andante, Where the Mountains Arrive
As the introduction moves on and the pace loosens a little, the clouds begin to part. Here you hear the alphorn tune, which I once sent to Clara Schumann in September 1868 for her birthday, with the words "Thus blew the shepherd's horn today!" After it comes the trombone chorale, a slow, solemn passage for the trombones, which are being heard for the first time in the whole symphony. The mood has gone from worried to hopeful, and it prepares the way for what comes next.Section 3: Allegro non troppo, ma con brio, or the Big Tune
Now the music picks up speed, and the main theme arrives, with the feel of a hymn that everyone could join in on. People noticed that it resembles the Ode to Joy from Beethoven's Ninth, and I reacted to that comparison rather dismissively. In 1877 the conductor Hans von Bülow went further and called the symphony "Beethoven's Tenth", which was not the kind of compliment I enjoyed. Listen to the theme on its own terms, though, because it is warm and full of confidence, and I think it holds up well by itself.Section 4: Più allegro, the Victory Lap
Near the end the tempo picks up again, marked Più allegro, and the music pushes forward with real excitement. The key that began so darkly in C minor now turns to C major, and the whole orchestra seems to step out into the sunshine. After the long road from the slow introduction, this ending is a triumph, and I wanted it to feel earned. When the last chords arrive, you will know that the journey you have been following has reached its goal.Your Turn at the Controls
Now it's your turn, so press play and let the music carry you along from beginning to end. While you listen, you might keep in mind the slow, dark opening, the alphorn, the trombones and the hymn-like theme we talked about. You don't need to catch everything, because the music does most of the work if you simply let it. I hope you enjoy this finale as much as I enjoyed writing it, and that the C major ending leaves you smiling.---
I began this finale in the shadows of C minor, and after all those years of work it was a joy to end it in the bright light of C major. Did you enjoy this listen guide to the finale of my Symphony No 1, the IV. Adagio - Più andante - Allegro non troppo, ma con brio? I hope it gave you a few things to listen for, and that the next time the alphorn tune sounds and the trombones step forward, you'll feel you know them a little. Music like this tends to reveal something new each time you return to it, and I'm still glad when someone takes the time to listen closely. There is much more to explore in Symphony No 1. The first three movements each have their own character, and the story of how the whole work came together is worth knowing too. If you'd like to go further, please click on the links provided and follow whichever one catches your interest. Then press play once more, and let me know whether the ending feels different now that you've heard how it all began.
